Would an un-retouched ad make you more inclined to buy a beauty product?

Makeup Forever HD Foundation Ad

Dove's Campaign for Real Beauty
Here are two ads that are “un-retouched.”
First of all, what is the definition of un-retouched? We can assume that while they may not have been edited to the point of looking unrecognizable, they have been at least adjusted to have the color and contrast look right. From working with photos and doing my own editing, I know that very few photos are perfect right from the camera. Despite the fact that the photos for these ads were taken by professionals with the means and skill to photograph their subject flawlessly, I still think that at least a little color correction went on.
That being said, let’s talk about the Makeup Forever ad. First of all, I love the brand. Their products consistently deliver high quality and intense pigment. I have yet to buy something from them that doesn’t live up to its claim. I do own the foundation that this advertisement is for, and it is the best foundation I’ve ever used. So, this ad has a leg up in that it is advertising a quality product. It lives up to what it promises, which is a rare and wonderful thing.
Would I buy this product based on the ad? I love that the photo used resembles the set-up of a Facebook photo. This is the kind of picture you see as many girls’ profile pictures. She looks like she’s ready to head out on the town, and is taking those pre-party pics with her phone. Given, she’s got a pretty flawless face to begin with, but you can actually see pores on her skin. It’s so much more real than any other foundation ad, where the model’s skin is airbrushed into absurdity. This ad would inspire me to buy the product, because I feel that it can actually offer me the flawless skin it promises.
Next, let’s look at the Dove ad. I appreciate the fact that the Dove ad uses “real women.” Because it was such a well known campaign, a lot of debate went down about how much the photos were retouched, the casting call for “flawless” real women, etc. I like the idea and the execution of the print ads was good, but these ads don’t work for me because there has been too much controversy behind them. Dove’s parent company, Unilever, also owns Axe, whose advertising is exactly what Dove supposedly stands against. It was extremely hypocritical to have a campaign claiming to be a revolution that would make real beauty culturally accepted while simultaneously putting out degrading, sexist ads for another brand. In this case, the means (great execution and ads) don’t justify the ends (a campaign with seriously flawed morals).